Compare and Contrast Essay Rubric – Five Paragraph Essay
Focus: *Does the writer have a clear focus?
1- Far Below Standards
*focus is not clear
2- Approaching the Standards
*focus is somewhat clear
3- Meets the Standards
*focus is clear
4- Exceeds the Standards
*focus is very clear
Organization:
*Do the ideas follow a logical sequenc
*Is there a clear beginning middle and end? *Does the essay contain 5 paragraphs?
*Does each paragraph have a topic sentence?
*ideas do not follow a logical sequ
*essay is incomplete
*ideas follow a sequence at times
*essay may be missing beginning or end
*ideas follow a sequence
*essay has a beginning, middle and end that is organized into 5 paragraphs
*each paragraph has a topic sentence
*ideas follow a logical sequence
*essay has an effective beginning, middle and end that is well organized into 5 paragraphs
*each paragraph has an effective topic sentence
Elaboration:
*Does the writer develop and support the ideas with sufficient relevant details and examples?
*Are the ideas supported throughout the writing?
*Compares and Contrasts
*ideas are not developed or supported
*does not provide facts or examples to support a comparison and contrast
*ideas may not be developed or supported at times
* does not use enough details for comparison and contrast
*ideas are developed and supported throughout
* uses most information for comparison and contrast
*ideas are well developed and fully supported throughout the essay
*uses all information for comparison and contrast Voice:
*Does the writer engage the reader with his own thoughts and feelings?
*does not engage the reader with own thoughts and feelings
*engages the reader at times with own thoughts and feelings
*engages the reader with own thoughts and feelings throughout the essay
*fully engages the reader with own thoughts and feelings throughout the essay
Language/Word Choice:
*Does the writer use language that's appropriate and interesting for thepurpose and audience?
*does not use language that is appropriate and interesting
*uses language that may or may not be appropriate and interesting at times
*uses language that is appropriate and interesting
*uses language that is appropriate and very interesting throughout the essay
Sentence Structure:
*Does the writer use correct and varied sentence structure?
*does not use correct or varied sentence structure
*uses correct and varied sentence structure at times
*uses correct and varied sentence structure throughout the essay
*effectively uses correct and varied sentence structure throughout the essay
Mechanics:
*Does the writing include correct: spelling, punctuation, capitalization, grammar and word usage?
*has more than 6 errors that interfere with meaning
*has 5 or 6 errors that interfere with meaning
*has 3 or 4 errors that do not interfere with meaning
*has no more than 2 errors and uses conventions effectively